Copyediting.com

because editing matters

  • Publications
    • Blog
    • Newsletter
    • Books
    • Email Newsletter
  • Individual Training
    • Master Classes
    • Recorded Classes
    • In-Depth Courses
    • Public On-Site Training
    • Custom Training Solutions
  • Group Training
    • Mentoring Groups
    • Custom Training Solutions
  • Editors’ Library
    • Ask Copyediting
  • Jobs
  • About
    • Bios
    • Advertise
  • Contact
    • Report a Site Error
  • Subscribe Now
    • Subscribe for Free
    • Individual Subscription
    • Organization Subscription

Judgment Calls

posted on March 5, 2014 by Erin Brenner

Judgment Calls

One of the signs of maturity in an editor is the realization that she imposes different sets of “rules” depending on the client’s preference. There are few indisputable rules, the editor realizes, as she is exposed to more and more sets of preferences.

Yesterday I blogged about the that/which distinction being a choice rather than a hard-and-fast rule. A judge emailed me directly to say that “folks whose readers depend on precision (as do those in my field) ignore the rule at their peril.” It’s hard to take issue with a group who focuses on language as much as we do. Though lawyers may want to structure their writing so that meaning doesn’t hinge on defining a single word—or on a “rule” that is not universally observed even within their own jurisdiction.

In the #GrammarChat for National Grammar Day, special guest June Casagrande said

“That/which” is more a style convention than a grammar rule #grammarchat

— June Casagrande (@JuneCasagrande) March 4, 2014

Several people in the chat said that they apply different rules depending on client. There; the mature editors who know that satisfying the client is key, not adherence to some Platonic ideal. Canadian editors continually balance this line between “Canadian practise” and “pleasing US readers.”

The latest issue of Copyediting Newsletter contains a couple related items. Daniel Sasnoski gives advice on how to “familiarize yourself with hotly contested areas of usage and places where you’ll have to make deliberate judgment calls.” And a handful of tools you can use to fight the zombies are given by Erin Brenner in this month’s “In Depth” column.

Hopefully, [sic] next week’s Judgment Calls seminar via Copyediting.com will offer even more solutions. John McIntyre promises to explain how “to make informed and appropriate editorial decisions.” And that is what we all aim for.

Other posts you may like:

  1. Teaching Editors: Developing Editorial Judgment
  2. Copyeditor / Using a Few Words, Telling / a Worthy Story
  3. I Hope You’re Bossy

Filed Under: Blog, Tip of the Week Tagged With: Erin Brenner, Grammar, Tip of the Week, Usage, Zombie Rules

Erin Brenner

About Erin Brenner

Erin Brenner is co-owner and publisher of Copyediting. She has been a publishing professional for two decades, working in a variety of media. Erin also runs editorial services company Right Touch Editing and teaches in UCSD’s Copyediting Certificate program. Follow her on LinkedIn and SlideShare.

Shopping Cart

My Account

  • Log In
  • Password Reset

Sign Up Now!

Copyediting's 2018 Freelancer Happy Hour

Sponsored by

Training

Translating Medicalese into English

James Harbeck

Thursday, May 16, 2018, 1–2:30 pm ET
Skill level: Intermediate
Instructor: James Harbeck

Mentoring Groups

Mentoring Groups from Copyediting

Jobs of the Week

Subscribe Now

Sign up for an Individual Subscription to get access to our bimonthly newsletter full of editing tips and up-to-date industry information.

Copyediting Weekly

Sign up to receive Copyediting Weekly, our email newsletter packed with news copyeditors need now.

Popular Posts

What a Copyeditor Earns
Copyeditor Training, Part 1
Wet Your Whistle and Whet Your Appetite

Blog Topics

Copyright © 2018 Pilcrow Group, Inc.

Privacy Policy