Copyediting.com

because editing matters

  • Publications
    • Blog
    • Newsletter
    • Books
    • Email Newsletter
  • Individual Training
    • Master Classes
    • Recorded Classes
    • In-Depth Courses
    • Public On-Site Training
    • Custom Training Solutions
  • Group Training
    • Mentoring Groups
    • Custom Training Solutions
  • Editors’ Library
    • Ask Copyediting
  • Jobs
  • About
    • Bios
    • Advertise
  • Contact
    • Report a Site Error
  • Subscribe Now
    • Subscribe for Free
    • Individual Subscription
    • Organization Subscription

Credible, Credulous, and Confusable

posted on April 12, 2017 by Andy Hollandbeck

Trust plaqueThere’s a lot of worry about credibility these days. While some statements are so incredible that only the most credulous will believe them, other people are so incredulous that they trust nothing but what they see with their own eyes, regardless of how credible the source is.

Which means that figuring out the truth is sometimes only slightly more difficult than keeping credible, credulous, incredible, and incredulous straight.

Credible

Believable; generally considered reliable

News organizations rise and fall based on how credible their journalists and reporting are. Having a high level of credibility means they have earned more trust. It takes years for a reporter to earn high levels of credibility, but (as Dan Rather, among others, can attest) only a single story to completely destroy it.

In the jargon of military reports, credibility has another meaning: “of sufficient quality or size to be militarily effective,” as in a “credible deterrent.”

Incredible

Too extraordinary or impossible to believe; hard to believe

Etymologically, incredible is simply credible with the negating prefix in-, so simply “not believable.” But as we have used it hyperbolically more and more over the last four centuries or so, it has taken on the more common meaning of “amazing or astounding” — so much so that noncredible has been gaining ground as an antonym of credible.

Credulous

Willing to believe, even on flimsy evidence

Of the four words covered here, this is the one you least want to describe you. More than one journalist has been burned by being too credulous when a juicy tidbit lands on their proverbial plate; because they want to believe it, they don’t thoroughly verify the truth or falsity of it before publishing it as fact.

They say there’s a sucker born every minute; those who get sucked in to the snake oil salesman’s schemes the quickest are likely the most credulous of the bunch.

Incredulous

Unwilling to accept a statement as true; skeptical

Although a certain amount of incredulity is healthy, it can be taken to extremes. If a particular person, news organization, or political group has lost all credibility, you are right to be incredulous — to be skeptical of what they say. But when taken too far, it’s a relatively small step from not believing anything they say to believing that everything they say is false, that they are incapable of telling the truth about anything.

 

Here is a little mnemonic that might help you keep these straight in the future: When it comes to news reporting, credulous and incredulous describe us, the readers, which leaves credible and incredible to describe the journalists and their claims.

Other posts you may like:

  1. 01/25/13 News Roundup
  2. Survey Finds Decreasing Attention on the Facts
  3. Want to Print the Truth? Use Your Copyeditors

Filed Under: Blog, Language Usage Tagged With: Confusables, Usage, Vocabulary

Andy Hollandbeck

About Andy Hollandbeck

Andy Hollandbeck (@4ndyman) has worked in various aspects of publishing since 2000. He is the founder of Logophilius Editorial Services and is currently copy editor of The Saturday Evening Post.

Andy has twice presented sessions about SEO at the annual conference of the American Copy Editors Society (ACES). On his blog, Logophilius, he dips into all facets of writing and editing, including editorial topics, interesting vocabulary, original short fiction, and some horrible, horrible poetry.

View Andy's Classes

Shopping Cart

My Account

  • Log In
  • Password Reset

Sign Up Now!

Copyediting's 2018 Freelancer Happy Hour

Sponsored by

Training

Translating Medicalese into English

James Harbeck

Thursday, May 16, 2018, 1–2:30 pm ET
Skill level: Intermediate
Instructor: James Harbeck

Mentoring Groups

Mentoring Groups from Copyediting

Jobs of the Week

Subscribe Now

Sign up for an Individual Subscription to get access to our bimonthly newsletter full of editing tips and up-to-date industry information.

Copyediting Weekly

Sign up to receive Copyediting Weekly, our email newsletter packed with news copyeditors need now.

Popular Posts

What a Copyeditor Earns
Copyeditor Training, Part 1
Wet Your Whistle and Whet Your Appetite

Blog Topics

Copyright © 2018 Pilcrow Group, Inc.

Privacy Policy